Showing posts with label Market Trends. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Market Trends. Show all posts

CRE Finance Council Recap - Optimism and Cash!

A colleague of ours in CBRE's Debt & Equity Finance group, Jason Brown, does a great job at sharing information on the debt markets with those of us in investment sales. Most recently, he provided a summary from the CRE Finance Council meeting assembled from him and his colleagues in DEF.

Interesting of note for us at the Insider is that the mood seems to support lending in the rust belt states like Ohio on just stabilized deals. Well, we can definitely attest to that. Separately, retail seems to be leading the pack on property type, but we would expect to see a big swing towards office and industrial this year. This is probably particularly true in secondary markets where STNL and grocery-anchored retail have been the most sought after assets in the last couple years. But enough of our commentary - on to the experts.

Several of the Debt & Equity Finance team members attended the semi-annual CRE Finance Council conference. I thought I would pass along the feedback received on the state of the credit markets, especially the CMBS/conduit market which has been making a comeback.

General CREFC Feedback

  • Mood of the conference was pretty optimistic as there is A LOT of liquidity in the CRE space. Not enough product to go around to satisfy all the piggies at the trough.
  • Recent blow out of spreads put a damper on some of the mood as there is very little risk tolerance for losing money as some of these institutions get back into this business. 
  • All the regulatory uncertainty is definitely having an impact on the industry. Nobody knows for sure what the rules of the road will be. Eg; risk retention, capital allocations in general, B Buyers not controlling the special servicer, ability to monetize the IO strip, requirement of B Buyers to hold their investments for 5 plus years, etc. Stay tuned. 
  • Depending on how the regulatory framework evolves, we will have better clarity on whether the non-bank owned Conduits can thrive. Most think the big commercial and I-Banks will be the major players when the dust settles, but this is not a certainty. 
  • 2011 issuance levels will probably be in the $40 to 50 B range. Very few are predicting more will get done this year. 
  • Not enough B Buyers in market now. Only 5 or so real buyers per some experts. Consensus is that buyers will emerge once the rules are set and yields are high enough.

Producer Feedback

Product/What kind of deals are Conduits winning?
  • Life Cos and GSEs winning the better product at reasonable leverage 
  • Conduits winning the higher LTV loans 
  • Go to Conduits for cash out refis 
  • They will go to secondary and tertiary markets ( $85M office bldg loan in Tulsa). Leverage goes down and structure goes up as the markets get smaller. 
  • Will lend in rust belt states of MI, IN and OH on stabilized deals 
  • Issuance YTD in 2011 heavily weighted to retail – approx 40% 
  • Conduits tough on acquisitions. Too much interest rate and execution certainty risk. 
  • Winning proceeds driven refis

 Comparing CMBS 2.0 Underwriting to version 1.0 
  • Similar to 1.0 back in 2003. Nothing crazy. More thoughtful, visiting the real estate and understanding the market and the deal 
  • Can only get basic structural constructs waived on very low LTV deals 
  • No benefit for short amortization structures. In fact it may cut proceeds due to higher constant and lower cash flows 
  • All underwriting to debt yields in 8 to 12% range depending on product, market, LTV, etc. Lowest for MF deals. 
  • Can get 75% LTV on most product if cash flow is there 
  • Some quoting 80%. Can get higher in capital stack by Conduit making a high leverage loan and securitizing the Sr Loan and stripping off a Mezz piece 
  • All underwriting income in place. Very little creativity.

 CMBS Process 
  • Not much fun. Expensive and cumbersome. Don’t expect your client to pat you on the back at closing. 
  • Slower, more thorough, and more reliable 
  • Better at setting expectations at the outset 
  • Real issues with spread volatility and holding spread and then proceeds 
  • Some Conduits marketing an ERL execution, but latest language is full of outs for the Lender. ERL Agreement completely one-sided. Be very careful here. 

 CMBS Legal Structure/Loan Docs
  • Lock box required and can be an issue 
  • Legal fees get high in a hurry. Min of $25,000 
  • Independent Directors required: one on loans less than $20M and two on bigger deals 
  • Tough but fair. More absolutes and fewer trade-offs 
  • Carve-outs are a big issue. Some reaching for more backdoors to recourse. Need very close attention and negotiation, if possible. 
  • Not much room for negotiation of loan docs. 
  • Non-consolidation opinions required. 

Northeast Ohio Market Snap Shot | Summer 2011

What a difference a year makes. Total U.S. investment transaction volume was up by 120% in 2010, compared to the same period in 2009, and overall cap rates were down 30 basis points (bps) to 7.4% according to Real Capital Analytics (RCA). This trend not only continued in 2011, but also sped up. Commercial property sales reached $44.2 billion through April, a 75% increase over the same period in 2010, at an average cap rate of 7.35%.

Continued investor demand for core assets in primary markets has been a significant factor to increased sales, but activity is increasing in secondary markets such as Northeast Ohio as well. We have seen a large uptick in activity over the last two quarters in properties offered for sale. Consequently, the trend in the secondary markets appears to be the reverse of the primary markets – new offerings are preceding sales. Since secondary markets generally present more risk and less growth, this trend makes sense as investors ease away from the primary markets as supply tightens.

Investors interested in Northeast Ohio are seeking safety or stability, or both. As a result, properties which attract the most interest include single-tenant, net-lease with long-term credit; grocery anchored shopping centers; medical office buildings near or on hospital campuses; senior housing; and sale-leasebacks. The amount of capital chasing these assets continues to increase, and the lack of supply in certain markets has created a “scarcity premium,” driving pricing to levels we have not seen since 2007, even here in Cleveland. This is combined with historically low interest rates and a return to more reasonable credit underwriting to drive the pace of property dispositions.

Owners of these properties should evaluate whether a possible sale now makes sense to take advantage of the scarcity premium. Low interest rates are also helping to stabilize cap rates for properties that may not necessarily fit into one of the “hot” property buckets. Either way, as we look out on the horizon, we see continued loosening of the capital markets and good opportunities for investors and owners alike.

CPPI Increase - Read the Fine Print

The Moody's/REAL Commercial Property Price Indices (CPPI) is showing a 3.6% increase for May, which follows a 1.7% increase for April. On the surface, this seems like good news. Unfortunately, the details and Moody's disclaimer limits the optimism the uptick in the CPPI may create. As Moody's managing director says, the increases are "tempered by low transaction volumes, forecasts for slowing macroeconomic growth and the rising risk of a double dip recession." Wow, that's not so rosy.

Low transaction volume is for sure. May's increase is based on just 107 sales nationwide, per Moody. We don't think that is a statistically relevant number of transactions to highlight price swings in the market nationally. Beyond that, as the previous post points out, commercial real estate is a local phenomenon right now. We don't have access to the underlying Moody data, but we'd be willing to bet most of those sales were on the coasts and southeast (except Florida).

The included chart, from MIT's Center for Real Estate, shows the real story, if there is one. Prices plummeted very quickly and if anything, have managed to stop the free-fall in the last six months. That has been our sense of the market as well, both nationally and in Northeast Ohio.

But we may yet see prices fall and rise depending on any number of factors. For example, STNL properties with 12+ year term and a quality tenant may continue to see price contraction. We have seen this in the last several months on Walgreen's. Alternatively, it is still challenging to find buyers for multi-tenant office space in the Midwest and thus very difficult to even price assets.

Confusion Persists, as TrafficCourt Astutely Points Out

If you haven't read TrafficCourt, run by David Bodamer, you should put it on your to-read blog list. It's a great CRE blog that is part of Retail Traffic, the monthly news magazine. We here at Commercial Real Estate Insider haven't posted anything in about two weeks because, well, we just don't see much worth posting. News continues to be regurgitated but in different forms and with different messages - the recovery is on, the recovery is off; REITs are great, REITs are seeing their debt terms tightened; buyers are back, buyers are skeptical and underwrite conservatively. It is just maddening.

To this point, TrafficCourt has a great post on exactly this, addressing the mainstream media's inability to understand the market dynamics and its oversimplification of the situation for their readers. The bottom line, with which we agree, is that the market is fragmented between the good, bad, and really bad, and both opportunities and pitfalls exist in pockets scattered throughout the US - there is no singular "market." It's a bunch of little markets. From our perspective in Northeast Ohio, David is right-on, but probably understates the situation, with this:

We’re going to see continued pain in some places alongside recovery in others. It does very much appear, though, that a bottom in values has formed. But I don’t think anyone can say for certain what the contours or speed of recovery in values is going to look like. And it’s going to play out differently in different markets and in different property sectors.
We encourage you to read the whole post. If anything, someone who can successfully use the word "zeitgeist" in their post (which yes, we had to look up too) is worth reading to us.

Nontraded REITs Continue to Stockpile Cash

A firm established last year to look at nontraded REITs, Blue Vault Partners, LLC, has published its 2010 first quarter review, which RetailTraffic overviewed. Not surprisingly, nontraded REITs are expected to raise 17% more in 2010 than in 2009, or about $7 billion. Due to the quick and reasonable liquid access to real estate ownership with professional management, REITs have done very well this year. So well, in fact, an investor with who we are negotiating on a deal actually brought up that he could get over a 10% yield with a nontraded REIT.

But therein lies the problem - that's not sustainable. The fees and overhead costs of running multi-billion dollar REITs can be significant and these REITs don't tend to use a lot of leverage. As the report points out, the median yield is only about 6.5%, which makes sense in our experience. For deals we've seen this year, at least with the health care REITs, the yields being sought range anywhere from 7.5% to 10% or 11%. Once salaries, overhead, fees, etc. are tacked on, how many hundreds of basis points are eaten? The other issue with investing in a REIT is limited use of leverage. The REITs that are still raising money have effective leverage of only 30%, according to the report. The REITs closed for the year at least have a leverage ratio of nearly 60%, but only about a third of REITs are closed. Though the market got leverage-drunk and is learning many lessons, 30% is way to low to generate a +10% yield on most investments.

Moody's Saying Prices Up, But Not By Much

Moody's just issued an investor report saying commercial real estate prices are up for the first time since January this year. The increase of 1.7% isn't much, and we view it as statistically irrelevant. The more important factor is that prices are not falling anymore. We do not believe there will be any real increases in cap rates in the foreseeable future. If anything, pricing should continue to improve as the wave of capital continues to roll. That capital is picky, and if fund managers/REITs/investors want to make any money, they are going to have to put that capital to use and start buying out of their strict guidelines. It will be slow, but we are starting to see signs of this.

"Nonresidential Construction Rebounding"

A couple leading indicators that CoStar has picked up on is showing signs commercial construction is on an upswing, and not from public works, i.e., stimulus money projects. The Construction Backlog Index and the Architecture Billings Index both were up over the last few months. These indices help determine what construction is either in the pipeline or is in early stages of planning and design.

We've written on new development and construction before here for Northern Ohio. The project in Toledo Marina District project seems totally dead - we recently visited Toledo and the development signs previously up were nowhere to be found. Financing just isn't going to happen. Newport Pavilion in Cincinnati is probably in receivership by now with millions in defaulted loans. Midtown Cleveland development is going to be a marathon, so while there's no new news to report, that means there is no bad news either.

But that's not to say new construction is happening, though whether it's "public works" isn't in question - it clearly is. Cleveland State University's campus is under a huge transformation, with numerous projects under way now, including new extensive new student housing. CSU also just announced they finally selected a developer for their massive, mixed-use project in what is now surface parking. According to the Plain Dealer, construction could start next year.

With new construction having been at a virtual stand still for going on two years, something has to give. We're hearing about a number of new, non-government projects in the early planning stages, which is consistent with the leading indicator increases.

Same story, different asset class

A story in Reuters today highlights the same buying problems and trends in multi-family that medical assets have experienced. The large players are going after the best-in-class assets, driving cap rates down while becoming unhappy with the properties coming to market. At some point, hopefully these trends translate into some interest for properties that aren't considered platinum. There are still very stable properties that are solid investments, whether in multi-family or medical.

Principal Global Investors' CEO - Buy Commerical Real Estate!

Even, as Chief Executive Jim McCaughan says, considering the "well-known refinancing issue" hiding around the corner, he feels the yields "are attractive" for brick and mortar investments and that "it's about time for commercial real estate." We couldn't agree more! Unfortunately, we're not seeing the deals at the opportunistic pricing everyone expected. Global Investors has even published a "why you should by CRE" paper meant for non-US investors. It has nice information, but fundamentally relies on under priced assets being available. While there are buying opportunities, we have yet to see the kind of value-added deals everyone assumed would be on the market by now. Sellers just haven't been playing ball unless someone takes their ball and gives it away. That just isn't happening to create real velocity. But we like Mr. MCaughan's enthusiasm and recommendation to start buying.


Large CRE Funds - Whose Got the Money?

Within the large CRE investment funds, there are basically three types: public REITs, registered but untraded REITs - the so-called private REITs, and private equity funds. We have seen for some time the ability of private REITs to amass capital. For example, a large private REIT we know focused on medical acquisitions has consistently raised $2-$3 million a day and another focused on retail is raising $3-$4 million a day. Contrast this with private equity firms, who have had their relative struggles raising money in this environment.

Two years ago, there seemed to be a prediction on private REITs as well - this article from Global Real Estate Monitor in April 2008 predicted substantial growth in private REITs. Of course, there's always exceptions to the rule, as Inland's recent inability to raise substantial cash demonstrates (they raised just $67 million from August 2009 through March 2010).

But it seems the time may be ripe to tap the public markets. According to CoStar, "there have been more than 90 filings by REITs since March 1 announcing more than $10 billion in new fund raising activity and seeking to raise more than $50 billion."  This filing activity was highlighted by the largest secondary offering ever, which was done by Macerich Co., raising $1.23 billion in a filing that closed in early April.

So who has the money? Everyone, it seems. Even at a relatively slow fundraising pace, the PE firms still raised nearly $10 billion last quarter. So capital will be, and is being, deployed into the CRE market. Now we just have to wait for the flood gates to open on bad CMBS loans.

Fed Beige Book - "Further Signs of Strengthening"

The Fed published the Beige Book yesterday, which discussed signs of improvement nationally. Here are some highlights from the main summary regarding Cleveland/Fourth District:

- Consumer Spending - Cleveland reported recent sales strengthened and noted that retailers expect sales to improve during the upcoming months

- Manufacturing - Cleveland reported positive results in metals and fabrication, and increased auto or auto component production

- Banking - Most banks in Cleveland reported weak consumer loan demand, although a few contacts saw a slight increase due to seasonal factors. Not surprisingly, Cleveland saw flat business loan volume and tighter lending standards for commercial mortgages.

- Commercial real estate - Activity was slow across the nation, but Cleveland saw some development in the energy and industrial segments

- Employment - Cleveland reported strong demand for temporary workers. A pickup in employment was noted in the manufacturing sector, with little change in staffing for retail, energy, transportation and banking.

Proof - CMBS is Back

Globest.com reported the closing of a $31.3 million CMBS loan through JP Morgan Chase to a Michigan REIT. Though exciting that CMBS is quickly coming back , keep in mind it will take some time to achieve the terms that were common 2+ years ago. This loan closed on just 60% LTV and a 10 year term. But for non-recourse debt right now, the LTV isn't getting too much better, with life companies at gnerally 65%. As our Debt & Equity team from Detroit has pointed out, it also takes very strong sponsorship, such as a large REIT, to get CMBS done right now.

Healthcare Bill Could Equal 60,000,000 new MOB SF

The historic healthcare bill signed into law this week is going to have a significant impact on commercial real estate, whether specifically intended or not. There is going to be a lot of discussion on what that impact will be as the months and years roll by. Co-Star has an article on the bill's impact, and at one point quotes an industry player that the bill could ultimately lead to 60,000,000 more feet of MOB based on the number of new patients entering the rolls of the insured. On the flip side, the bill contains strong prohibitions on physician-owned hospitals, which will have a significant impact on current and future developments and currently existing hospitals.

Changes in Mark-to-Market? FASB proposes new standards.

The Financial Accounting Standards Board is proposing that banks expand their use of mark-to-market accounting to include loans and other financial assets, as reported by the WSJ. Though marking assets to market values can make sense in a vaccum of financial analysis, the real world implications are huge. The problem is that markets, like historical costs, do not always represent the real value. Bigger than that though is the fact that financial statements can only provide limited, historical information. In a market moving and changing as fast as today's, trying to rely on information that can be up to several months old and that provides no predictive insight on where values will be, can create major issues, as we've seen. For example, making banks adjust their minimum capital based on asset values that may be outdated by the time their published doesn't seem like a good use of information.

Challenges in Cleveland's Real Estate Market

The Plain Dealer, Cleveland largest newspaper, published a mildly interesting article today. Anyone that has read this blog should know, probably more intimately than most, the general problems and issues with, and potenital fixes needed for, commercial real estate. And not just in Cleveland. But its good to know what the non-real estate news sources are writing about CRE anyway.