Showing posts with label Capital Markets. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Capital Markets. Show all posts

CRE Finance Council Recap - Optimism and Cash!

A colleague of ours in CBRE's Debt & Equity Finance group, Jason Brown, does a great job at sharing information on the debt markets with those of us in investment sales. Most recently, he provided a summary from the CRE Finance Council meeting assembled from him and his colleagues in DEF.

Interesting of note for us at the Insider is that the mood seems to support lending in the rust belt states like Ohio on just stabilized deals. Well, we can definitely attest to that. Separately, retail seems to be leading the pack on property type, but we would expect to see a big swing towards office and industrial this year. This is probably particularly true in secondary markets where STNL and grocery-anchored retail have been the most sought after assets in the last couple years. But enough of our commentary - on to the experts.

Several of the Debt & Equity Finance team members attended the semi-annual CRE Finance Council conference. I thought I would pass along the feedback received on the state of the credit markets, especially the CMBS/conduit market which has been making a comeback.

General CREFC Feedback

  • Mood of the conference was pretty optimistic as there is A LOT of liquidity in the CRE space. Not enough product to go around to satisfy all the piggies at the trough.
  • Recent blow out of spreads put a damper on some of the mood as there is very little risk tolerance for losing money as some of these institutions get back into this business. 
  • All the regulatory uncertainty is definitely having an impact on the industry. Nobody knows for sure what the rules of the road will be. Eg; risk retention, capital allocations in general, B Buyers not controlling the special servicer, ability to monetize the IO strip, requirement of B Buyers to hold their investments for 5 plus years, etc. Stay tuned. 
  • Depending on how the regulatory framework evolves, we will have better clarity on whether the non-bank owned Conduits can thrive. Most think the big commercial and I-Banks will be the major players when the dust settles, but this is not a certainty. 
  • 2011 issuance levels will probably be in the $40 to 50 B range. Very few are predicting more will get done this year. 
  • Not enough B Buyers in market now. Only 5 or so real buyers per some experts. Consensus is that buyers will emerge once the rules are set and yields are high enough.

Producer Feedback

Product/What kind of deals are Conduits winning?
  • Life Cos and GSEs winning the better product at reasonable leverage 
  • Conduits winning the higher LTV loans 
  • Go to Conduits for cash out refis 
  • They will go to secondary and tertiary markets ( $85M office bldg loan in Tulsa). Leverage goes down and structure goes up as the markets get smaller. 
  • Will lend in rust belt states of MI, IN and OH on stabilized deals 
  • Issuance YTD in 2011 heavily weighted to retail – approx 40% 
  • Conduits tough on acquisitions. Too much interest rate and execution certainty risk. 
  • Winning proceeds driven refis

 Comparing CMBS 2.0 Underwriting to version 1.0 
  • Similar to 1.0 back in 2003. Nothing crazy. More thoughtful, visiting the real estate and understanding the market and the deal 
  • Can only get basic structural constructs waived on very low LTV deals 
  • No benefit for short amortization structures. In fact it may cut proceeds due to higher constant and lower cash flows 
  • All underwriting to debt yields in 8 to 12% range depending on product, market, LTV, etc. Lowest for MF deals. 
  • Can get 75% LTV on most product if cash flow is there 
  • Some quoting 80%. Can get higher in capital stack by Conduit making a high leverage loan and securitizing the Sr Loan and stripping off a Mezz piece 
  • All underwriting income in place. Very little creativity.

 CMBS Process 
  • Not much fun. Expensive and cumbersome. Don’t expect your client to pat you on the back at closing. 
  • Slower, more thorough, and more reliable 
  • Better at setting expectations at the outset 
  • Real issues with spread volatility and holding spread and then proceeds 
  • Some Conduits marketing an ERL execution, but latest language is full of outs for the Lender. ERL Agreement completely one-sided. Be very careful here. 

 CMBS Legal Structure/Loan Docs
  • Lock box required and can be an issue 
  • Legal fees get high in a hurry. Min of $25,000 
  • Independent Directors required: one on loans less than $20M and two on bigger deals 
  • Tough but fair. More absolutes and fewer trade-offs 
  • Carve-outs are a big issue. Some reaching for more backdoors to recourse. Need very close attention and negotiation, if possible. 
  • Not much room for negotiation of loan docs. 
  • Non-consolidation opinions required. 

Northeast Ohio Market Snap Shot | Summer 2011

What a difference a year makes. Total U.S. investment transaction volume was up by 120% in 2010, compared to the same period in 2009, and overall cap rates were down 30 basis points (bps) to 7.4% according to Real Capital Analytics (RCA). This trend not only continued in 2011, but also sped up. Commercial property sales reached $44.2 billion through April, a 75% increase over the same period in 2010, at an average cap rate of 7.35%.

Continued investor demand for core assets in primary markets has been a significant factor to increased sales, but activity is increasing in secondary markets such as Northeast Ohio as well. We have seen a large uptick in activity over the last two quarters in properties offered for sale. Consequently, the trend in the secondary markets appears to be the reverse of the primary markets – new offerings are preceding sales. Since secondary markets generally present more risk and less growth, this trend makes sense as investors ease away from the primary markets as supply tightens.

Investors interested in Northeast Ohio are seeking safety or stability, or both. As a result, properties which attract the most interest include single-tenant, net-lease with long-term credit; grocery anchored shopping centers; medical office buildings near or on hospital campuses; senior housing; and sale-leasebacks. The amount of capital chasing these assets continues to increase, and the lack of supply in certain markets has created a “scarcity premium,” driving pricing to levels we have not seen since 2007, even here in Cleveland. This is combined with historically low interest rates and a return to more reasonable credit underwriting to drive the pace of property dispositions.

Owners of these properties should evaluate whether a possible sale now makes sense to take advantage of the scarcity premium. Low interest rates are also helping to stabilize cap rates for properties that may not necessarily fit into one of the “hot” property buckets. Either way, as we look out on the horizon, we see continued loosening of the capital markets and good opportunities for investors and owners alike.

MBA Conference Highlights - Optimism with Lingering Anxiety

Greg Greene is a Senior Vice President in CBRE's Debt & Equity Finance and has a long, successful career in the capital markets. Greg attended the recent MBA conference and was great enough to share his thoughts with us, which we are providing to our readers. We have put in bold several of Greg's points we found most interesting or telling about where we are today and italicized our thoughts. 

Mortgage Bankers Association Conference Overview:

The spirit of the conference was one of optimism; however some anxiety remains as the difficulties of 2008 through early 2010 remain fresh on the minds of most lenders.


• There is a very substantial amount of capital committed to commercial mortgages in 2011.

• Most lenders are concerned that there will not be enough product to absorb the capital committed to these mortgages. This is a continuing problem throughout the commercial real estate market, not just on the financing side. We consistently find demand outpacing supply. This is changing, but we believe all of 2011 will be needed to re-balance the market.

• Life companies have a large appetite for commercial mortgage placement due in part to the fact that the yield on these mortgages is favorable to the yield on corporate bonds.

• Some money center banks are starting to quote non recourse deals for ten year terms, making them more competitive with life companies and CMBS at the longer term.

• Many lenders stated this is starting to feel somewhat like 2005.

• The CMBS platforms are very active and their underwriting is reflecting the competition in the marketplace. This does not imply that the CMBS lenders or others are engaged in loose underwriting, but the box is certainly expanding for the definition of a “financeable” deal. This is good to see. A year ago, we felt lenders were too confident, which borrowers did not appreciate.

• Numerous lenders expressed some doubt that all the current CMBS platforms would survive. The expectation is for mergers and for a few to drop out as volume is not sufficient to warrant the continued investment in the platform.

• Lenders are exploring ways to improve yield and get more money invested. There is a wide expectation that bridge loan opportunities will provide this outlet as debt is provided for assets that must be repositioned or assets that will be released from the commercial banks currently holding those assets.

• There is a desire (hope?) that the commercial banks will begin to more aggressively sell off the real estate assets they hold. The banks have seen a material recovery in the value of many of those assets and many of the banks are now in a better capital position to sell the assets and absorb a much reduced loss. However, like it or not, most people believe that “kick the can” has served the banks and the industry rather well over the last two plus years. We have already seen a pick up in requests from commercial banks to start moving, or at least to begin valuing, under performing assets. We hope the "pretend and extend" phenom is over.

• Many lenders stated that real estate values have recovered faster than anticipated in many markets.

• The CMBS platforms and a few life companies stated they will finance to a 75% LTV. This confirms what I am currently seeing in today’s market.

• Some lenders will provide forwards---but this number is relatively few and the number of months to go forward is limited.

• A substantial amount of capital is dedicated to mezz debt. Rates start at around 8% and increase from there with a rate of 8% to 10% prevalent for deals in the 70% to 80% LTV range. Terms range as long as ten years.

• Most lenders expect more dispositions from special servicers throughout 2011.

• Most lenders remain underweighted in industrial mortgages and would very much like to add industrial to their portfolios.

• Some life companies have become very competitive with Freddie and Fannie and are now winning business from the GSEs. Considering that Congress is upended the GSE's, this is probably a good thing for the real estate market; unless of course we're going to see pricing from the GSE's go up as the government guaranty subsides.

• Many lenders maintain a preference for the mezz debt structure instead of the preferred equity structure that gained some popularity in the preceding months.

• The current recovery remains a jobless recovery and there will be no real economic recovery until the U.S. can generate jobs. The recent positive jobs report for January is already being refuted by numerous sources that consider it more “accounting trickery” than fact.

• The “joke” coming out of last year’s MBA was that loan spreads fell 50 basis points in the three days of the conference as everyone realized how much money was re-entering the commercial mortgage market in 2010. The “joke” this year is that the previously held expectation of $50 billion in CMBS lending in 2011 has now become $70 billion. We shall see, but don’t be surprised. This remains very light compared to the $250 billion plus for CMBS issuance in 2006.



With all this said, expect the following as we get further into 2011:

• The competition for new loans will intensify. Lenders will increase LTV’s, finance more non-core assets, provide a longer interest only period, enter more tertiary markets, accept lower DSCR, etc. These are the logical actions for an industry that likely has more debt capital available than deals to absorb that capital.

• However, do not expect silly lending practices. The mortgage industry is filled with smart people who remain cognizant of the lessons of the recent past.

• CMBS will be very competitive and will provide much of the needed capital to finance lesser quality assets and quality assets in tertiary markets. Expect CMBS loan spreads to fall as the year progresses.

Highlights from HUD Lender Conference

Jason Brown, our Debt & Equity expert out of Detroit , attended the Midwest HUD MAP Lender's Conference the week of May 17th in Columbus, Ohio. Below are his highlights from the conference, but here is a good big-picture:
Overall, HUD is open for business. They are making changes to protect the viability of their programs going forward. They are not increasing mortgage insurance premium, nor are they reducing LTV's and DSCR to limits below their competition. HUD remains the highest leverage financing for multi-family and senior housing investors with assets in the Midwest.

Highlights From FHA/HUD MAP Lender Conference

Highlights from BOMA Medical Office Conference

Steve and Scott attended the BOMA Medical Office Building and Healthcare Facilities Conference held in Chicago this past week.

If there is one phrase that summarizes our take-away from the conference, it would be “there is a lot of capital chasing too few deals.” Private REITs have clearly led the pack here, gobbling up whatever assets they can find with their hordes of newly raised cash. Beyond that, there are all kinds of players, most of whom are well-capitalized themselves, waiting for acquisitions, development, and joint ventures, including private equity, public and private REITs, hospitals, and developers.

The mood could not have been different from a year ago. This year’s conference was nearly all positive with significant market activity to discuss and the highest turnout in its history. Even new development is seeing a strong resurgence. Several national developers reported full pipelines of strong demand for new on and off-campus MOBs, surgery centers and other healthcare facilities. Clearly the access non-profit health systems have enjoyed to the bond market is helping move new projects forward, but one cannot overlook the surge of capital focused on this space right now as a significant contributing factor.

This is not to say there aren’t uncertainties. Obama-care, which in many ways is really just insurance reform, does not address long-term cost containment, among a number of other issues, and the debt market still seems to provide more support to the aspirin industry than would-be borrowers. But these issues tend to be ancillary to medical real estate investment and ownership. Fundamental questions may exist about whether primary care physicians or specialists will fare better in the next 5-10 years, but little concern seems to exist about whether either of those two groups (or any affiliated health system) will need additional real estate. The resounding consensus seems to be yes, they will.

So with another successful gathering of medical real estate junkies behind us, we look forward to seeing the predictions and shared expectations bare some fruit. We have highlighted the more pertinent predictions and expectations below.


Pricing/Cap Rates:
- Cap rates have compressed 50-75 bps since a year ago and range anywhere from 7.5% for on-campus, Class A MOB to 9.5%-10% for off-campus, Class B.
- Additional compression is possible, but will likely be on lower quality assets and be incrementally small. The best assets are probably priced as good as they’ll get for awhile.
- Bank underwriting, which is slowly beginning to matter again, will help provide a sanity-check on cap rates.

Buyer Profiles
- The REITs have had a buying spree, particularly Healthcare Trust of America. HTA has been raising $2-$4 million a day on average and has not been shy about putting it into acquisitions. In our opinion, HTA alone has caused cap rates for Class-A to compress by ±25 bps from a year ago.
- Big REITs have pursued nearly all deal sizes, but are starting to look larger. This will begin opening doors for other players, like private equity and non-REIT investors, to pursue deals.
- Leveraged players have generally been sidelined by all-cash REIT buyers whose yields just need to cover dividend payments and who generally don’t underwrite with exit plans.
- Foreign investors are showing “tremendous interest,” as one panel participant put it, in the medical real estate market due to the higher relative returns and lower volatility compared with many European markets. Healthcare reform has, however, kept some foreign capital at bay due to a perceived uncertainty of outcome in its application.

Acquisition targets/criteria
- This conference attracts larger players, who by necessity, go after assets that will generally align them with health systems. For that reason, many of the participants commented they have sought on-campus assets. One fund commented that with the right tenant mix and fee-simple ownership, they will go off-campus. We predict off-campus assets become more attractive as good on-campus assets become more difficult to find.
- Buyers are seeking assets with longevity and stable returns, which is generally determined by the strength of the nearby health systems (especially if they are a tenant), the property’s cash flow compared against rent to calculate a coverage ratio, the ownership structure, e.g., fee simple v. ground leased, and the overall tenant mix.
- Senior care is a target asset class for most of the same buyers of MOBs, though there are significant underwriting differences and the need for a well-tested operator.

FASB Changes to Lease Accounting
- The panel that addressed this topic did not have any serious concerns related to the proposed changes to lease accounting. The consensus was that analysts and ratings agencies are sophisticated enough to understand that any changes simply move things around and do not alter fundamental performance or economic position. As one panelist said, it will remain cumbersome for hospitals to own and manage real estate regardless of the accounting standards.

Development
- Developers have full pipelines of new development, most of which is from tabled projects over the last two years. Health systems have been raising money and will continue to have access to capital, which, combined with a trend to bring more physicians in-house, will lead to a need for new real estate.
- National developers are looking to partner with local developers
- Investor/buyers, such as REITs, will fund development but vary widely on what and how to fund it. Some will JV while others won’t, and those that do seem to recognize the value local developers provide and seek to partner with them.
- LEED-certified construction is becoming very popular
- Regionalization of health systems will lead to new freestanding emergency departments with some MOBs as a way to limit costs while expanding footprint size
- Market size and location may or may not matter; it just depends on the developer. In a tertiary market, the returns might have to be slightly higher, but if the facility is sized right for the market, the returns probably don’t need to be much better
- There is a growing trend to redevelop retail space to medical use because:
  o Retail provides immediate access to an existing consumer base
  o Providers can leverage stronger branding of their names
  o There will be a higher need for primary care as the insurance rolls expand
  o Occupancy costs are generally lower, especially in the current real estate market
  o Retail vacancy can provide immediate occupancy
  o End-cap users, like Blockbuster, are leaving and providing premium locations
  o Hospitals and providers want to be near their customers
  o Retailers can leverage increased daytime traffic, particularly as most medical consumers going to these locations tend to be women

Principal Global Investors' CEO - Buy Commerical Real Estate!

Even, as Chief Executive Jim McCaughan says, considering the "well-known refinancing issue" hiding around the corner, he feels the yields "are attractive" for brick and mortar investments and that "it's about time for commercial real estate." We couldn't agree more! Unfortunately, we're not seeing the deals at the opportunistic pricing everyone expected. Global Investors has even published a "why you should by CRE" paper meant for non-US investors. It has nice information, but fundamentally relies on under priced assets being available. While there are buying opportunities, we have yet to see the kind of value-added deals everyone assumed would be on the market by now. Sellers just haven't been playing ball unless someone takes their ball and gives it away. That just isn't happening to create real velocity. But we like Mr. MCaughan's enthusiasm and recommendation to start buying.


Proof - CMBS is Back

Globest.com reported the closing of a $31.3 million CMBS loan through JP Morgan Chase to a Michigan REIT. Though exciting that CMBS is quickly coming back , keep in mind it will take some time to achieve the terms that were common 2+ years ago. This loan closed on just 60% LTV and a 10 year term. But for non-recourse debt right now, the LTV isn't getting too much better, with life companies at gnerally 65%. As our Debt & Equity team from Detroit has pointed out, it also takes very strong sponsorship, such as a large REIT, to get CMBS done right now.

Changes in Mark-to-Market? FASB proposes new standards.

The Financial Accounting Standards Board is proposing that banks expand their use of mark-to-market accounting to include loans and other financial assets, as reported by the WSJ. Though marking assets to market values can make sense in a vaccum of financial analysis, the real world implications are huge. The problem is that markets, like historical costs, do not always represent the real value. Bigger than that though is the fact that financial statements can only provide limited, historical information. In a market moving and changing as fast as today's, trying to rely on information that can be up to several months old and that provides no predictive insight on where values will be, can create major issues, as we've seen. For example, making banks adjust their minimum capital based on asset values that may be outdated by the time their published doesn't seem like a good use of information.

Debt - Back in Action in the Midwest

The below is the latest update from CBRE's Debt & Equity team that covers Michigan, Ohio, and Indiana. The important points seem to be 1) financing is available, and 2) though slightly higher rates than borrowers might like, its non-recourse.

Permanent Financing for Stabilized Assets
We continue to see signs of life in the credit markets. Banks largely remain on the sidelines, with the exception of community banks and credit unions. Life companies continue to cherry pick financing trophy assets in trophy markets with trophy sponsors. However, portfolio and balance sheet lenders are offering an alternative way to finance stabilized properties on a non-recourse basis.


I wanted to spotlight a loan program that will finance deals in the Midwest:

• $5 - $50 million
• 3-5 year term, may go longer in select cases
• Up to 75% LTV on “as is” value
• Acquisition or refinancing
• Stabilized multi-family, retail, office and industrial properties
• 7.0% - 8.5%
• Amortization up to 30 years
• Non-recourse
• 1.00% origination fee to lender
• Escrows for taxes, insurance, replacement reserves, tenant improvements/leasing commissions and immediate repairs